|
|
Review of I Cheers a Dead Man's Sweetheart: 21 Painters in Britain
at De La Warr Pavilion, Bexhill-on-Sea, 15 March – 29 June 2014
The Journal of Contemporary Painting Volume 1 # 1 ISSN 2052-6695 (pub. 2015, pp 168–172)
Jeffrey Dennis, Chelsea College of Arts
The upstairs space at the De La Warr stands three-quarters empty with two composite works, by Bruce McLean and Lisa Milroy, hugging the rear walls. The Milroy — Party of One, 2013 — consists of a cluster of patterned, layered dress shapes, each on its own hanger; apparently similar, but upon close inspection, each comprised of different kinds of black, white and painted material. The McLean — Some Cardboard Caro Cards with Henry, plus Henry Barry Henry Barry and Constantin, 2010 — combines large, overlapping painted panels, featuring images of Henry Moore-like sculptures and wedges of flat colour. The foremost is mounted on an industrial-grade, paint-splattered trolley, and accompanied by a folding chair, presumably direct from McLean's studio. Both imply performance, movement and that actors, or the artists themselves, will step forward to animate these painted elements. Even if it were not the case that, each week, a waitress from the adjacent cafe actually obliges (she dons one of Milroy's 'dresspaintings' and takes a stroll round the show), both works would still declare the artists' affinity with live art and might also have been appropriately included in the recent Tate Modern exhibition, A Bigger Splash1. These however are the exceptions: the focus elsewhere is firmly on the idea of painting as a specialist activity with its own competing traditions, each work the artist's personal response to the world, realism at a remove, honed and reiterated from within the studio.
The exhibition is full of daring pairings and mini-duels; artists corralled, by close vicinity, into paint-offs with unlikely partners. One of the most exhilarating of these brings together Hayley Tomkins' Knife VIII (a real dinner knife, covered in paint and suspended on the wall like a thrown weapon) and Frank Auerbach's To the Studio (Camden Town vigorously re-engineered from adventure-playground timbers under a thickly plastered sky). The latter artist's unrelenting, daily commitment to his practice sets the tone for the show's celebration of the studio as a hermit's cave of artistic research. The title of his painting, with an added exclamation mark, could be the clarion-call of the catalogue texts. Auerbach is one of a quartet (with Jeffery Camp, Leon Kossoff and John Wonnacott) of the most senior painters in the show flexing their gnarled painting sinews with the command and assurance of veteran weight-lifters. The other painter of their generation included here, Frank Bowling, is represented by works that emphasise his role as outrider of Modernism and tester of boundaries (one painting, with overlaid stripes of bright coloured canvas, contains a strand-line of actual detritus from his studio floor) rather than, as he might have appeared from his room of poured and dripped paintings recently at Tate Britain, an exponent of an exclusively process-driven practice. But process is certainly a crucial catalyst for Jacqui Hallum, Hayley Tomkins and Jessica Warboys whose compositions of blots, stains and puddles are the outcome of chemical or tidal action or simply evaporation as much as the artists’ touch, with at least a ambivalent fiction maintained that the appearance of the work is the inevitable outcome of using materials in certain ways, rather than aesthetic considerations. With the exception of Gary Wragg, whose paintings recall an earlier era's more hedonistic indulgence of colour and gesture for its own sake (he may be surprised to find fresh allies amongst some recent graduates), throughout the show, abstraction tends to be approached obliquely, more often referred to rather than embraced directly, like a disreputable uncle. In 'refusing to clutter [the show] with peripheral questions about what constitutes painting practice'2 perhaps the selectors have tended to exclude those practitioners whose work is overtly that — i.e. a manifesto for what they feel painting should be — and reflect a contemporary unease with calls to revolution; with 'isms', with exclusivity; with the kind of painting fundamentalism that provoked progressive experiments in Fauvism, Cubism, Futurism or Minimalism.
The exhibition's title is taken, not as this reviewer first thought, from some lost Raymond Chandler novel, but from A. E. Housman's paean to the continuity of rural life at the end of the nineteenth century3, its seasonal cycles oblivious to the passing of individuals. In a somewhat sermon-like passage within his catalogue essay, Dan Howard-Birt (co-curator with David Rhodes) draws an analogy between the poem's celebration of the unsentimental persistence of these cycles of harvest, recreation and procreation, and the historical persistence of painting as an evolving practice. His claim that 'in this studio-based pursuit of meaning ... we found a liveness' is inevitably set against death — not, thankfully, as in 'The Death of Painting', which nearly every curator of a painting exhibition seems compelled to cite, and then refute — but as in the death of painters, the inevitable fact that only serves to highlight the life-affirming persistence of paintings. I have doubts about the poem's usefulness to the argument here. The narrator's assurance to his dead friend, that horses continue to plough the fields, sounds nostalgic and wistful to the modern reader, with our historical hindsight of what the two World Wars had in store for Britain's village communities. Is there not a risk that we may draw the opposite analogy: that painting is a traditional but doomed practice that the new digital technologies will eventually sweep aside like a tractor overtaking a plough-horse?
One artist refers directly to the poet's most famous work: continuing the exhibition's experiments in speed-dating for artists, Sophie Von Hellermann's A Shropshire Lad is painted directly on the wall, her coloured strokes framing with careless exuberance Alessandro Raho's Ben (could Ben be a Shropshire lad himself? I would guess Telford, most likely). In Raho's work, the flat, red heart motif on the subject's Moschino tee wrinkles into his arm-pit; surface Pop-pattern beginning to wrap itself around the human form. In another (the most consummate) of the exhibition's many depictions of two-and-a-half dimensions, Pheobe Unwin's Copy Table employs a contemporary version of Renaissance grisaille technique. In the works of Mantegna or Crivelli, this would be partly intended to demonstrate how painters could outflank sculptors: monochrome images of sculptural bas-reliefs springing to life alongside fuller renditions of living flesh4. Unwin builds a close-toned, layered and patterned surface, scored and ripped, with quasi-objects drawn in simple, oblique projection. I would enjoy seeing it installed beside the illusionistic garden fresco from the House of the Golden Bracelet in Pompeii5. Both evoke a time-worn space of quiet enchantment.
Henry Krokatsis presents assemblages of the bevelled and shaped decorative mirrors familiar from every suburban hallway (sourced from Bexhill's many charity shops?), intercut and stacked to confront the visitor with a fragmented reflection, an over-familiar metonymy if intended to suggest psychological disturbance. The mirrors are separated from, and placed adjacent to their monochrome-painted wooden backs, trapping us between Art Deco fantasy and materialist blankness. In another inspired pairing, next to his work is John Wonnacott's The Blue Dressing Gown 2007. The artist, dressed for the hospital, sits in the tungsten glare of his nocturnal studio, surrounded by the six panes of a large bay window which in his other paintings opens on to an expansive view of the Thames estuary. But in the dead of night the dark rectangles only reflect the artist back on himself, reminiscent of Bacon's claustrophobic space-frames. The idea of painting as a fracturing prism can be carried on to William Daniels' elaborately crafted still-life paintings of crumpled tinfoil that splinters colour and light, confounding any judgement of space or distance. The whole surface presses forward with neurotic insistence, a literal depiction that nevertheless baffles the viewer; in effect a hallucinogenic equivalent of Van Hoogstraten's or Gysbrechts' seventeenth century trompe l'oeil conundrums.
Howard-Birt cites, in his introduction, the 1994 exhibition Unbound: Possibilities in Painting6, which presented to a British audience many unfamiliar artists from Europe and USA whose work seemed at first eccentric or marginal, but who subsequently become essential references in all art school crits. Unbound was one of succession of painting exhibitions, from the mid-1980s onwards, which, by revealing recent developments in USA and Europe, shook up the previous somewhat complacent critical context for painting in Britain. He is careful not to assert that this show will recalibrate our taste in a similar way. Many of the artists featured here are familiar names. His strategy is, instead, to invite us to engage with the particularities of each painting, enhanced and highlighted by its adjacency with other artists' work. This approach is amply justified by the lively and risky interactions throughout the show, the result of the curators' close attention to the potential of each painting. The exhibition itself, rather than its poetic preface, provides the strongest riposte to that often-forecast End of Painting. The curators' marathon tour of artists' studios has brought about an exhibition that demonstrates painting as an activity with the capacity to reflect its own time, to evolve under the influence of other media and emerging technologies and to maintain a nuanced dialogue with its own history.
1. A Bigger Splash: Painting After Performance, Tate Modern, London, 14 November 2012 – 1 April 2013
2. Howard-Birt, D. (2014) Both Strange and Wonderful, I Cheer a Dead Man's Sweetheart, (unpaginated) De La Warr Pavilion
3. Houseman, A. E. (1896), Is My Team Ploughing (Poem XXVII), A Shropshire Lad, London: K. Paul, Trench, Treubner
4. As explored in Sculpture in Painting, Henry Moore Institute, Leeds 10 October 2009 – 10 January 2010
5. Exhibited in Life and Death in Pompeii and Herculaneum, British Museum, London 28 March – 29 September 2013
6. Unbound: Possibilities in Painting, Hayward Gallery, London 3 March – 31 May 1994
Back
|